Late-afternoon light on a contemporary limestone apartment building beside an older buff-brick residence on an Upper West Side block.

Where the Upper West Side's Next New Condos Are Coming From

In the week of September 14 to 20, Penthouse West at The Henry, 211 West 84th Street, went into contract at an asking price of $26.9 million, as The Real Deal reported. The five-bedroom duplex had been priced at $25.3 million when the building launched sales in September 2024. Its asking price went up over two years of selling. By that point, 39 of the building's 45 units had closed, at an average of about $3,000 per square foot.

The Henry stands for something larger on the Upper West Side this fall. The new condominiums now setting the neighborhood's condo prices are close to sold out, and the buildings coming next together hold roughly 50 apartments. That supply problem bears on a buyer comparing neighborhoods in two ways. The condo figures being quoted for the Upper West Side describe a group of buildings with very few units left. For most buyers, the market they will actually buy in through 2028 is the co-op, and co-ops did better per square foot than condos in the third quarter.

The buildings behind the condo numbers are almost sold

Four new-development condominiums have set the top of the Upper West Side condo market over the past two years, and each had sold at least four-fifths of its units at its most recent count this year.

The Henry, designed by Robert A.M. Stern Architects for Naftali Group, had six units left to close as of September, and Penthouse East was still listed at $27 million. At 50 West 66th Street, the 127-unit Extell tower was about 80% sold in March 2026, according to The Real Deal, and closings were already underway. Two of its tower residences closed in a single week in early June: #53N for $35.73 million and #40N for nearly $24 million, both slightly above asking.

In that same June week, a full-floor four-bedroom on one of the top floors of 200 Amsterdam Avenue closed for $12 million in white-box condition, and the building was reported 97% sold. Farther north, The Westly at 251 West 91st Street closed a 3,840-square-foot, five-bedroom combination unit for $10.05 million. It was nearly 90% sold in June, with its remaining apartments asking from $3.995 million for a three-bedroom to nearly $12 million for a five-bedroom.

Those percentages come from the spring and summer, and inventory has kept moving since. Still, every one of these buildings was already in the last fifth of its sales, or closer.

About fifty apartments, spread across three addresses

In October 2025, the New York Post reported a Corcoran Sunshine Marketing Group projection that the Upper West Side would get only 51 new condo units through 2028. Between 2016 and 2019, 869 were delivered. The 94% drop was the steepest of any Manhattan neighborhood that group tracks. The same article said large parcels are rare and that historic district designations cover much of the neighborhood, which limits the scale of new building.

A year later, the buildings behind that number can be named, and they add up to almost exactly 51 units.

The largest is 200 West 88th Street, an 18-story building by Nortco Development, also designed by Robert A.M. Stern Architects, with 36 apartments of three to five bedrooms. Listings went live in October. Three-bedrooms start at $5.375 million, four-bedrooms at $6.995 million, and a five-bedroom penthouse with a terrace and two loggias is listed at $17.75 million. It has a limestone base, a light brick facade, setback terraces and all-electric systems, the first all-electric building from that architecture firm.

Etage, at 214 West 80th Street, is a seven-story building of six condominiums by ZHL Group. Sales are targeted for the fourth quarter of this year and delivery for the second quarter of 2027. At 2160 Broadway, at the corner of West 76th Street, a ten-condo project was in excavation in August, with completion slated for August 2028, according to New York YIMBY.

That makes 36, 6 and 10 units. The next project large enough to change the neighborhood's supply is Extell's planned tower at 77 West 66th Street, with roughly 430 condominiums, and New York YIMBY reports its expected completion as December 2030.

At 200 West 88th Street, the entry price is a $5.375 million three-bedroom. Anyone who wants a new Upper West Side condo in the next two years and is buying below that price is mostly looking at resale units in the buildings described above.

Two condo figures, one explanation

How the Upper West Side condo market looks this year depends on which measure is used, and both measures point back to the same buildings.

By average price per square foot across all condo closings recorded in 2026 through November 9, the Upper West Side was at $1,847, up 3.2% from 2025. That was the largest gain of Manhattan's six submarkets, and the increase was attributed partly to closings at The Henry and 50 West 66th Street. Manhattan as a whole averaged $1,773, essentially flat.

By median, the third quarter looks different. PropertyShark's Upper West Side figures for Q3 2026 show 119 condo sales with a median price of $1.8 million, up 19.2% from Q3 2025. The median price per square foot for those condos fell 3.3% over the same period.

A median price that rises nearly a fifth while the median per-foot price slips means bigger apartments made up more of the quarter's sales. An average that climbs because a few towers are closing $12 million to $35 million units does not show that a typical condo square foot gained value. Both figures are being pulled up by large new-development closings. Those closings are running out, and the measures will lose that lift as the remaining units sell.

The co-op tier gained per square foot

Most Upper West Side buyers will end up in co-ops, and the third-quarter co-op figures did not depend on a few towers.

In Q3 2026, PropertyShark counted 197 co-op sales on the Upper West Side, against 119 condo sales. The co-op median price was $1.2 million, up 5.3% from a year earlier, and the median price per square foot rose 5.2%. Price per square foot rose about as much as the median price did. That suggests the co-op gain came from what buyers paid per foot rather than from a change in which apartments sold, and it is the opposite of the condo pattern.

Activity was thinner overall. Q3 2026 had 320 Upper West Side sales across all property types, down 17.9% from a year earlier, with an overall median of $1.4 million, up 3.3%, and an overall median of $1,406 per square foot, down 6.9%. The neighborhood-wide per-foot decline and the co-op per-foot increase appeared in the same quarter. That happens when the overall figure blends together several kinds of product moving in different directions.

Greenwich Village moved the other way. In Greenwich Village in Q3, condos drove the headline gain while co-ops slipped. On the Upper West Side, co-ops gained per foot and condos declined.

What this changes for a buyer comparing neighborhoods

The Upper West Side's new-construction shortage was already the story a year ago. In that October 2025 report, Corcoran found new-development sales up about 41% year over year in the third quarter while resale condo and co-op sales were flat, and Extell's cheapest listing at 50 West 66th Street was around $3.6 million. The 2026 figures show what came after. The new buildings sold through, and the co-op tier gained per square foot.

A buyer weighing the Upper West Side against other neighborhoods should start with three practical points.

The first is where new construction remains. Buyers who need central air, new systems and condo ownership have a few remaining sponsor units and resales in the 2015 to 2026 generation of buildings, plus 200 West 88th Street and Etage. Each of those comes with its own pricing history. At The Henry, a sponsor raised the penthouse asking price over two years of sales, and that is useful context for any negotiation in a building where the developer has few units left to sell.

The second is that co-op pricing deserves the closest attention. With 197 co-op trades in one quarter and the co-op median per foot up about 5%, the best evidence for a West End Avenue or Riverside Drive apartment is recent sales in the same building and line. Neighborhood figures that are inflated by condo towers are a weaker guide. Our guide to Upper West Side co-op boards covers what the approval stage asks of a buyer in this tier.

The third is to read every quoted condo figure for the Upper West Side with its source buildings in mind. An average lifted by closings at 50 West 66th Street says something about 50 West 66th Street. For a broader comparison of the two paths, new development vs. resale on the Upper West Side lays out the differences in cost and timing.

A few questions we hear

Is 77 West 66th Street a reason to wait? On the reported schedule, completion is expected in December 2030. That is several years past the 2028 window covered by the supply projection, so it has no bearing on what is available to buy in the near term.

Are there still new condos below $5 million? In June, The Westly's remaining availabilities started at $3.995 million for a three-bedroom. At 200 West 88th Street, the opening asks this fall begin at $5.375 million. Below those levels, new-condo inventory on the Upper West Side consists mainly of resales.

Which part of the neighborhood is getting the new buildings? The current projects sit along the Broadway corridor and its side streets, at West 76th, 80th and 88th Streets, and the large future tower is near Lincoln Center at West 66th Street.

If you are deciding between one of the last new Upper West Side condos and a prewar co-op on the same blocks, Jed Lewin, Esq. can put building-level closings, remaining sponsor inventory and recent co-op sales in the same line side by side before you make an offer. Request a confidential consultation.

Let’s Find Your Dream Home

Get assistance in determining the current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.

Follow Me on Instagram