Thanksgiving is one week away, on Thursday, November 26. Two Greenwich Village food businesses opened this fall and are selling Thanksgiving pre-orders for the first time. Calabash on Christopher Street stops taking orders for its holiday sides today, Thursday, November 19. Fillings, the pie pop-up on Bleecker Street, stops tomorrow. The older shops on Bleecker give you more time, and the order in which the deadlines fall decides what a Village table can still include.
Seven Dates Between Now and the Long Weekend
Here is how the next ten days run, from the earliest cutoff to the last pickup:
- Thursday, November 19: Last day to pre-order Calabash's "The Whole Spread," which the restaurant's site lists as "Preorder by Nov 19."
- Friday, November 20: Grub Street gives Fillings' order deadline as "Order by November 20."
- Sunday, November 22: Murray's Cheese on Bleecker Street begins its Thanksgiving-week hours, opening at 7 a.m.
- Tuesday, November 24: Last day to change a Kerber's Farm pie order, according to LovelyNYC's Thanksgiving takeout guide. Fillings' 9-inch pie pickups also start that day.
- Wednesday, November 25: Second and final Fillings pickup day, 11 a.m. to 8 p.m.
- Thursday, November 26: Calabash's spread is pre-ordered for this date, and Murray's on Bleecker is closed.
- Through Sunday, November 29: Magnolia Bakery's Thanksgiving pickup window stays open.
The two businesses with the tightest deadlines both opened in October. The two with the most slack have been on Bleecker for years. The rest of this post follows that pattern from the west end of Christopher Street to the original Magnolia storefront.
Christopher Street Sells Everything but the Turkey
Calabash opened at 183 Christopher Street, near Weehawken Street, on October 2 with daytime service. Dinner followed on October 9. Patch describes it as an Afro-Caribbean bakery and brasserie from chef Camari Mick. Mick is a Food & Wine Best New Chef, a four-time James Beard Award semifinalist for Outstanding Pastry Chef, and a former executive pastry chef at the Musket Room and Raf's. Tajeh Porter is chef de cuisine. The room covers 1,300 square feet, seats 30, and draws on West African, Caribbean and Eastern Seaboard cooking.
Its Thanksgiving offer is the only one in this group built around side dishes. The restaurant's site describes The Whole Spread, at $145, as "Everything but the turkey!" It feeds two to four people and includes one of each:
- Mac and cheese, in an 8-by-8-inch tray
- Collard greens with smoked turkey neck, in a 13-by-7-by-2-inch tray
- Candied yams, in the same size tray
- Cornbread dressing, in the same size tray
- An 8-inch Calabash sweet potato pie
The holiday pre-order page also sells candied yams on their own for $28 and the mac and cheese for $32, both marked for November 26. Pickup is at the restaurant on Christopher Street.
Calabash is open only a few days a week, which explains the early cutoff. Eater NY reported that daytime service runs Thursday through Sunday. Dinner is a single 6:30 p.m. seating on Friday and Saturday, booked and paid in advance, and the restaurant serves fermented drinks and nonalcoholic cocktails in place of alcohol. Patch put the Friday and Saturday prix fixe at $175, including tax and nonalcoholic pairings. When a kitchen keeps that schedule, taking holiday orders a week ahead is how it plans its production.
One Block of Bleecker, Three Calendars
About ten minutes east, three Thanksgiving options sit within a few doors of each other on Bleecker Street, and each runs on a different schedule.
Fillings, 272 Bleecker Street. This is the newest of the three. Village Reader reported that the mini-pie company opened its first in-person shop here, between Morton and Jones streets, as a holiday pop-up running October 29 through December 24. For Thanksgiving it is selling full 9-inch pies, a size the company had not sold in person before:
- Caramel Apple, $65
- Coconut Key Lime, $65
- Classic Pumpkin, $66
- Bananas Foster, $66
- Brownie Pecan, $68
Pickup at the pop-up is Tuesday, November 24 or Wednesday, November 25, between 11 a.m. and 8 p.m. Grub Street tasted close to 20 new Thanksgiving pies this year and put founder Katie Kaplan's apple crumb fourth among its runners-up. The review notes that Kaplan has been working on the recipe since 2022 and makes the crust with stone-milled flour. A shop that only exists through December 24 has a short holiday season to work with, and two pickup days is how it fits Thanksgiving into it.
Kerber's Farm, 264 Bleecker Street. The Village Sun announced in early 2023 that Kerber's Farm Provisions, the Huntington, Long Island farm store, was opening a small shop on this stretch. Its Thanksgiving collection has 14 pies. Most cost $34, including Apple Crumb, Cherry Crumb, Kerberry Crumb and Pumpkin. Pecan and S'mores Moose cost $36. The gluten-free, vegan and sugar-free versions cost $37. Orders are for New York City pickup only, and you choose a pickup day in the cart before checkout. The shop's regular hours are 7 a.m. to 8 p.m. Sunday through Thursday and until 10 p.m. on Friday and Saturday.
Kerber's allows changes until November 24, four days later than Fillings' cutoff, and its prices are about half of Fillings' for a pie of the same 9-inch size. The gap reflects what each shop is. One is a year-round store with a set pie list and pickup days you pick yourself. The other is a seasonal pop-up whose Thanksgiving pies share two afternoons of pickup.
Murray's Cheese, Bleecker Street. Murray's handles the cheese course. Its holiday hosting page promotes a Small Fireside Bites cheese and charcuterie board at $165 and a Large Holiday Party board at $250. Those boards ship nationwide with a delivery date chosen at checkout, so they are not picked up at the Bleecker counter. The holiday hours page matters more to anyone shopping in person. The Bleecker store opens at 7 a.m. starting November 22, is closed on Thanksgiving Day, and reopens at 9 a.m. on Friday, November 27.
The Shop With the Longest Window
Farther up Bleecker, Magnolia Bakery's original location gives the most room for a late decision. Its Thanksgiving menu lists four 9-inch pies: Apple Crumb, Pumpkin, Pecan and Pumpkin Praline. It also offers Apple Crisp Pudding, Thanksgiving cupcakes, a pie-slice sampler and a "Worksgiving" sampler. Pickup runs from November 3 through November 29, and both advance and as-soon-as-possible pickup are available.
A household that wants Calabash's sides has until today. One that wants Fillings has until tomorrow, per Grub Street. Kerber's allows changes until the Tuesday before the holiday, and Magnolia's pickup window runs through the Sunday after.
After Thursday, the Pop-Up Keeps Going
Fillings stays on Bleecker after Thanksgiving. The pop-up runs through Christmas Eve, and Village Reader reports hours of 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. on Wednesday, Thursday and Sunday, and 11 a.m. to 11 p.m. on Friday and Saturday, or until the pies run out. Its standard menu centers on Coconut Key Lime and PB & J, two seasonal flavors rotate weekly, and five-inch pies come whole or as slice flights. The 11 p.m. weekend close makes it a late-night dessert stop on a block where few places stay open that late.
A third pastry kitchen opened this fall on Bedford Street. The team behind Zimmi's opened Bar à Part next door at 72 Bedford, at Commerce Street, on October 7. Eater describes it as a 15-seat wine bar and cafe with small plates and savory and sweet pastries by Clodagh Manning, who previously worked at London's Lyle's. Bar à Part has no Thanksgiving pre-orders, but it adds to the list of places nearby for pastry once the holiday week is over.
Hosting this year? We keep track of these Bleecker and Christopher Street openings the same way we follow the blocks around them. For questions about the Village beyond Thanksgiving week, Jed Lewin, Esq. and the team are glad to talk. Request a confidential consultation.